Category: Old Neopets

Looking to buy old Neopets? Our selection of Year 1 Neopets and unconverted Petpets is exactly what you’re looking for!

All Neopets come delivered on their own unknown original accounts to ensure maximum safety!

You know that Fat Cat is calling your name…

Showing 1–16 of 54 resultsSorted by latest

Quick View
Random Year 1 Neopet
$34.99
Rated 5.00 out of 5

Own a relic of Neopias past! A Neopet created in the very first year of Neopets! All pets come delivered on their own accounts in a random name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 2 Isnewee
$25.00

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y2 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 2 Swirly
$25.00

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y2 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 1 Isnewee
$45.00
Rated 5.00 out of 5

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y1 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 1 Swirly
$45.00
Rated 5.00 out of 5

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y1 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 2 Speck
$25.00

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y2 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 1 Speck
$45.00
Rated 5.00 out of 5

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y1 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 2 Snappy
$25.00

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y2 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 2 Sluggo
$25.00

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y2 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 1 Snappy
$45.00
Rated 5.00 out of 5

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y1 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Y1 Sluggo
$45.00
Rated 5.00 out of 5

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y1 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 1 Seamonkeys
$45.00
Rated 5.00 out of 5

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y1 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 1 Scruffy
$45.00
Rated 5.00 out of 5

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y1 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 2 Ruby
$25.00

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y2 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 1 Ruby
$45.00
Rated 5.00 out of 5

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y1 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart
Quick View
Year 2 Prissy
$25.00

Own a relic of Neopias past! This is the original Unconverted Petpet! This Petpet comes attached to a Y2 Neopet! The Neopets are delivered in a RANDOM name format.

Add to cart